Creatine Pills vs Powder: Which Is the Better Choice?

Creatine comparison: Pills and powder side by side

Throughout this article, we will settle the debate of creatine capsules vs powder to determine which one is better for promoting health and fitness benefits. Ultimately, the discussion can be quickly settled depending on your lifestyle, financial allowances, and personal taste. 

Quick Takeaway:

  • In the debate of creatine pills vs powder, one does not provide more benefits than the other. It all comes down to personal preference. 
  • Creatine supplementation has been heavily researched and backed by science to promote muscle gains and enhance athletic performance
  • Between creatine pills and powder, each has its pros and cons. The weight of each can vary depending on each person’s tastes and preferences. 
  • When choosing a creatine supplement, it’s best to go with a creatine monohydrate version over a creatine HCL alternative, as creatine monohydrate has more research backing its benefits. 

Creatine Pills vs Powder – Which Is More Effective? 

Comparing creatine forms: Pills vs. powder
Chart showing pill preference rising
Source: Everflex Fitness 2024

According to our research, more people prefer pills over powder with their supplements, but only by a small 3% margin. 

Are creatine pills better than powder? It’s time to end the debate!

When it comes to creatine monohydrate pills vs powder, there has been much discussion on whether pill or powder form promotes the most benefits for optimal progress and results. Though they are different forms, these creatine supplements provide the same benefits.

At the end of the day, with powder creatine vs pill, it comes down to personal preference. 

Why Use Creatine Supplementation?

Creatine supplement usage: 36%
Source: Everflex Fitness 2024

Based on our research, 36% of people take creatine supplements, with 9% having taken them in the past. So, between creatine monohydrate capsules vs powder, is the hype about creatine supplements in sports nutrition and with fitness enthusiasts worth it? 

Taking creatine supplementation, whether in powder or pill form, has been deeply researched and connected with numerous benefits for muscle tissue and adenosine triphosphate (ATP) production. 

Creatine helps enhance athletic performance and improve muscle strength. Taking creatine daily is often used for building muscle mass and reducing muscle damage by athletes and fitness enthusiasts looking to maximize their gains from training. 

Creatine Pills – The Pros & Cons

Are creatine pills good enough to provide quality benefits compared to creatine powder? Here are some of the pros and cons of creatine pills to consider when purchasing a creatine supplement! 

Pros Cons
Easy to take Not absorbed as quickly as creatine powder
Can take on-the-go when traveling Can’t be added to protein shakes or liquids
No flavor Creatine capsules cost more than powder form 
Fits easily in a gym bag  Limited choices for dosing

Creatine Powder – The Pros & Cons

Taste profiles guide choices

Source: Everflex Fitness 2024

From our research, more responders revealed that flavor and mixability impacted their decision to purchase a powder supplement rather than texture or whether it is easy to take on-the-go.

Between creatine powder vs pills, there are pros and cons with each, though some can be more prominent to each individual depending on personal preference. With creatine powder, some favorable pros can encourage individuals to purchase the powder over the pill form of creatine. 

Pros Cons
Costs less than creatine pills More challenging to take on the go or when traveling 
Flavor creatine powder options for added taste More difficult to take in a gym bag than creatine pills
Can be mixed with water or added into protein smoothies Texture may be a deterrent for some individuals
Digests faster than creatine pills  Flavor options can be limiting 

Creatine Monohydrate Powder vs Pills – The Differences

Are creatine pills as good as powder? What are the differences between creatine powder and capsules?

Whether it be powder or capsule form, both are effective supplements. For a cheaper and more convenient option to take when traveling, the creatine pill may be the best option for you.

The powder form of creatine may be best for speedier effects as it will be absorbed quicker in the digestive system since it is already broken down. It is also easy to mix powders with liquids or protein smoothies, which are also more quickly digested than capsules. 

Creatine Monohydrate vs Creatine HCL – Which Is Best for Powder or Pill Supplements? 

Creatine monohydrate is one of the most widely researched forms of creatine used often in supplements. This form of creatine has been backed by research to promote exercise performance, build muscle, support brain function, and encourage energy production for resistance training. 

Creatine HCL, or creatine hydrochloride, is creatine bound with hydrochloric acid to enhance solubility and absorption. Unfortunately, there is not enough evidence backing the claims of creatine HCL’s benefits when compared to creatine monohydrate, which is more dedicatedly studied. 

Whether creatine pill or powder, we recommend sticking with a creatine monohydrate version of this supplement form due to the more researched background of creatine monohydrate compared to creatine HCL. 

Which Form of Creatine Is Right for You – Creatine Powder vs Pills?

Regarding this discussion on creatine powder vs pill, one may be preferable to the other depending on the individual’s preferences.

Creatine pills may be best if you’re more sensitive to flavor and texture. If you’re searching for an easy-to-take supplement because you travel a lot, then creatine pills may be best for you.

A creatine powder may be better if you like adding flavor to your supplemental daily routine. If you want a cheaper alternative for your creatine supplements, the powder form is less expensive than the pill form. 

Creatine Pills vs Powder: When to Use Each

To date, no solid evidence supports the superior benefits or more optimal results of taking creatine pre-workout versus post-workout. Between the two forms, creatine pill vs powder, creatine powder is more readily absorbed than the pill, so its benefits of improving sports performance and strength during high-intensity exercises may come in handy. 

Based on your preferences, the creatine supplement dosage can be taken in multiple doses throughout the day, pre-workout or post-workout, to promote muscle growth.

What About Creatine Chews vs Powder?

Creatine chews are a yummy addition to your daily routine if you love gummies and sweet treats. Choosing a creatine chew may be more alluring than creatine powders for individuals who are picky about texture and flavor. They can easily be taken on-the-go or with vitamins in the morning. 

A creatine chew option will cost more than creatine powder, so it’s important to consider this if cost is a factor you need to keep in mind. This alternative still provides the same benefits as the creatine pill or powder form. 

Best Creatine Pill

Elm & Rye – Creatine Capsules & Powder

Overview

Dedicated to quality and sustainability efforts, Elm & Rye has established itself as a noteworthy supplemental brand for its efforts. Each customer is guaranteed satisfaction with its third-party tested products that promote only the highest quality in each supplement. 

These creatine pills by Elm & Rye are no exception. Easy to take on-the-go, these creatine pills provide all the benefits of creatine, from muscle growth to enhanced athletic performance. If you want to move past capsules and try a creatine powder, then Elm & Rye has those too! 

Highlights

  • Contains sustainably sourced ingredients
  • This supplement is free from:
    • Gluten
    • Sugar
    • Milk
    • Eggs
    • Fish
    • Crustacean shellfish
    • Tree nuts
    • Wheat
    • Peanuts
    • Soybeans 
  • Each batch is tested in a third-party lab
  • This product promotes:
    • Lean muscle mass
    • Muscle recovery
    • Energy 
    • Better athletic performance 
  • Featured by Forbes, Men’s Journal, & The Salt Lake Tribune 

Price

PRODUCTAMOUNTPRICING
Elm & Rye Creatine CapsulesSingle Pack (30 Servings)$44.99
Elm & Rye Creatine Capsules2-Pack$84.99
Elm & Rye Creatine Capsules4-Pack$159.99
Elm & Rye Creatine GummiesSingle Pack (60 gummies)$64.99
Elm & Rye Creatine Powder450g/1lb$44.99

Bottom Line

Elm & Rye has left no openings for poor quality in their supplements. So whether you like capsules or powder, Elm & Rye has the best quality creatine supplements! 

Best Creatine Powder

Transparent Labs Creatine HMB

Transparent Labs Creatine HMB Bottle

Overview

Transparent Labs has made a name for itself in the supplement and fitness world for its dedication to exactly what its brand name suggests – transparency! 

This creatine HMB supplement promotes Transparent Lab’s dedication to no hidden ingredients. It is free of artificial ingredients or additives and boosts endurance, strength, and lean muscle mass. It is the ultimate supplement to promote gains and improve athletic performance in athletes and fitness enthusiasts. 

Highlights

  • No artificial sweeteners
  • No artificial coloring
  • No artificial preservatives
  • Gluten-free & non-GMO
  • There are many delicious flavor options to choose from, including:
    • Blue Raspberry
    • Hawaiian Splash
    • Peach Rings
    • Sour Grape 
  • It incorporates the widely researched creatine monohydrate for its incredible health benefits.
  • Benefits from this supplement include:
    • Increased endurance
    • Enhanced strength
    • Promotes lean muscle mass 

Price

PRODUCTAMOUNTPRICING
Transparent Labs Creatine HMB297g/0.65lbs$49.99
Transparent Labs Creatine HMB594g/1.31lbs$89.99

Bottom Line

Transparent Labs has the best creatine powder supplement, hands down! Boasting all the enticing benefits of creatine, this powder supplement will grant all the magical enhancements of creatine to promote progress in your fitness journey! 

Frequently Asked Questions

Do creatine capsules work?

Yes, creatine capsules work. They are made into pre-measured doses, so you don’t have to worry about measuring out creatine each time you want to take the supplement. 

Do creatine pills work the same as powder?

Creatine pills and creatine powder work the same. As creatine powder is already broken down, it is more quickly digested when consumed compared to the pill form.

What do creatine pills look like?

The appearance of creatine capsules and pills will vary depending on the brand. Many brands choose to establish a certain appearance of their supplements to associate with their brand. No touted differences in benefits are stressed upon the appearance of each pill or capsule. 

Are there amino acids in creatine? 

Yes! Creatine is made up of three amino acids and three enzymes. These elements promote creatine’s benefits of improved protein synthesis to support muscle growth and lean body mass.

Kaelyn Buzzo | ISSA CPT & Nutrition Coach

Kaelyn Buzzo | ISSA CPT & Nutrition Coach

I am an ISSA-certified CPT and Nutrition Coach with a BA in Creative Writing and a Minor in Nutrition.

Learn More About Kaelyn

More posts from Kaelyn Buzzo | ISSA CPT & Nutrition Coach

Testimonials

“Since training with Mike at EverFlex for the past couple of years, my overall strength and fitness has improved dramatically.  I am now able to perform exercises I would never have attempted on my own and continue to see both physical and mental gains at the gym.

Mike is always willing to share his expert knowledge and answer any questions I come up with. His knowledge on nutrition is admirable and his dedication to helping people is commendable. Mike’s sessions are always fun, and he continues to mix up every training session, so it never gets boring.”

Lisa Atkins

“Overall Mike and his company EverFlex are awesome. Not only do they always have a positive and encouraging attitude, but are able to personalize the sessions to fit my needs. They are always able to provide in depth explanations of each of the exercises, and a back story on their importance! Mike definitely makes the gym a better and less intimidating place!”

Taylor Brown

“Best trainers I have ever had the privilege to train with! I have been training with Mike for the past 7 years, after searching for a specialist that could help with active recovery of a sport related injury. Not only did Mike get me back to normal and active again, but he has helped to optimize my fitness and overall health. Work outs are always fun and challenging, tailored to the achievement of personal goals. Mike is knowledgable and passionate about his field, strives to be current with fitness trends and personal education, and genuinely cares about the well being of his clients. Thank you, Mike, for keeping me healthy, active and in a state to enjoy my many pursuits!”

Carrie Ferguson

“I’ve trained with Mike since before EverFlex started up and he’s dedicated to making sure that your training is specific to your fitness levels and needs. He gives diet and lifestyle suggestions that are easy to integrate into your daily routine and is incredibly knowledgeable and personable.”

Trevor Hunt

Book Your Consultation

Get in touch with our expert trainers to discover how EverFlex and the Fitness AutoPilot (Beta) can get you closer to your wellness goals. Prioritize your health and connect with us today.

    EverFlex Personal Training App